Skip to main content

For-learning schools

For-profit schools vs. For-learning schools

I hear a lot of banter about how profits are bad, people who earn them are bad. Wait what?!

Bill Gates...one of the world's most prolific philanthropists, has made A LOT of profit by creating something that a lot of people needed/could use and presenting it in an arguable user-friendly way. He made profit, which allowed him to grow, make more profit, retire, and give it all away.

Profits allow us, the public, to play a role in the firing of people/services that we don't like, or to vote with our feet. Don't like those shoes, don't go back to that store. Disappointed with the Windows OS, buy an Apple.

So what about government services? What's their incentive to provide excellent service? Profits? No.

Back to the question...what incentive do government agencies have to give a superior product. They can't fired. They have no competition. So your telling me that they do it out of the goodness of their hearts? While the greatest philanthropist worked for profit and THEN gave it away? See United States Postal Service as an example.

I believe we should have the conversation...within the current system...that school's are for learning entities. Not so much for-profit. As an aside, if the result of a pro learning institution is more money, with which they can replicate those results, power to them for so doing.

We need to re-frame the conversation around a bottom line that denotes learning.  How is that defined? By us, the consumer. Same as it is when we decide what to eat or in what format we are entertained. I don't like the golden arches as a food source. Clearly so many still do. I don't understand it, don't need to, they vote with their feed and their money. I don't have wifi or cable, I don't own a TV, do Netflix, or Amazon, of Hulu...some do. How do I know this? Because those services exist by virtue of the public's choosing.

Districts seek tax payer $ through bond elections - which is a lot like marketing. The old saying "Butts in the seats" gives schools a per pupil funding model...like customers or clients who contract with an organization.

I wonder what would happen if we took away the current funding model and asked schools to actually compete for student enrollment? Which is what has, in reality, emerged as the ruling force school choice today.

Charter schools approximate this model, and the innovation/creativity is astoundingly clear. Hi Tech High, W.H.E.E.L.S., Northpoint Expeditionary Learning Academy, Great Hearts Academies, Phoenix Collegiate Academy, Pioneer Preparatory School...are prolific examples of what a dilluted funding system can accomplish when we're allowed to compete.

Parents, if you don't like your school, fire them. Vote with your feet, and your tax dollars. Vote no on bond elections. Give tax credit $ to a deserving school. Enroll your children in a program that meets their needs.

For more information on cultures of deeper learning, please visit the Center Creek Institute.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

1.5 Reasons to Take a Different Path - The Hippy-Cow Way

The Hippy-Cow Way I remember early in my career asking a question something like, "Why don't we try [insert idea here]?"  And the quick reply, "Because this is the way we've always done it." Wow. 2020 is teaching us that the way  we've always done things..does not work.  Yeah.  The age-old rut that can trap us all. Frustrating isn't it? As a child growing up in the Aspen Valley, I remember traveling many miles along Highway 82.  Glenwood to Carbondale, then to Basalt, and on to Aspen.  Two lanes most of the way, it was and is the main route connecting all of these Rocky  Mountain towns.  The drive can be breath-taking in the Fall. And most take this route because, well, it's the route we always take. It's familiar. Safe. Known. Well traveled. You get the idea. There are other ways to get where you're going. Roads less traveled that hold great sites and great reward. One of my favorites is the Hippy-Cow Way. Known only to our fam...

Prayer for an Educator

It's rare to sit in the staff lounge for the 30 minute lunch break  we get and be able to reflect on one's career. Today was one such day...causing a flood of memories.  I offer this prayer for educators May you have protection when you do the home visit on the little girl who's father beat her with a 2x4 for getting a C.  May you have wisdom when consoling the teacher who gave her the C. Go with courage to sit next to the little girl who all alone weeps at the lunch table because she has lice. Teach her mother with tenderness. Be vigilant when the little boy describes the cigarette burn on his eye given him by his mother because he complained he was hungry. Hold fast at the 9 o'clock hour, still at school prepping for another day, while your own children go to sleep not having seen you all day. Have wisdom when all at home is falling down around you - and you know the children at school need you now more than ever. Be with joy when t...

5.5 Principles of Principals

At present, I'm out of work.  Long story,  and we don't have time for it here.  I've been thinking, a lot, about the things I miss about working in schools, and sort of " if I had it to do again " approach.  I believe I will get another shot - I'm very good at what I do, and I believe in second chances.   Take note... Kindness - being a school leaders is more stressful than you think.  I've been in and out of the mix enough to know the difference between job stress and principal stress.  Be kind to yourself.  Deliberately schedule time out.  Eat the foods that heal your soul and your body.  Breathe. Breakthrough - on the advice of someone I admire, I attended The Breakthrough Coaching lead by Malachi Pancoast.  Changed my whole way of looking at resource management, secretaries, and clarified my role as a principal.  Do yourself, and your colleagues a solid favor, go.  Establish a life & a career . Situa...